Re-writing the narrative

With the world becoming increasingly unpredictable, FIRE Deputy Editor Philip Mason, talks about the urgent need for emergency services to continue to provide pro-active community leadership:

The end of April witnessed the annual Counter Terror Expo, taking place, as in previous years, at London Olympia. As ever, it proved to be one of the year’s most interesting events, offering many perspectives on a subject which – to this writer’s mind at least – is one of the most compelling for anyone involved in the emergency services.

However, as well as providing delegates with up-to-the-minute intelligence on how to respond to the ongoing terror threat, the event is also instructive from a broader strategic, cultural perspective. In other words, not just on how to tackle those intent on causing massive disruption and mitigate the effects of their actions, but how to stop them in the first place by persuading them that it’s a bad idea. Continue reading

Posted in Assistant Editor at FIRE | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Fire Sector’s integration challenge

As the Americans up the bar in integrating fire protection into sustainable, green efficient housing, FIRE Editor Andrew Lynch calls for the UK Fire Sector to raise its game

The success of the Callow Mount retrofit project was evident for all those in attendance at the launch of the report on April 12th (see May issue of FIRE). Make no mistake, this represented an historic day in the progress of sprinkler installations in England.

That the retrofit should a) be so affordable at just over £1,000 per flat and b) be quick and efficient, is a great credit to BAFSA and collaborators on this project. Add in the fact that the retrofit was in a high-rise block gives more power to the sprinkler lobbyist’s elbow. If it is so cost-effective for multi-storey buildings, imagine how much cheaper for sheltered accommodation and the like, where some prominent speakers felt such retrofits should be directed.

Attendees learnt that one of the reasons for this success was that then CFOA President Peter Holland’s challenge to the fire industry to significantly reduce the cost of installation. In effect, the Fire and Rescue Service had upped the ante and the fire industry rose to that challenge. It represents a perfect integration of the whole Fire Sector coming together to make a difference.

Over in the US, the National Fire Protection Association has gone one step further and partnered with industry to launch a new green home exhibition to show the environmental benefit of home fire sprinklers.

According to the findings of a study by the Home Fire Sprinkler Coalition, greenhouse gases released by burning buildings can be reduced by 98 per cent when automatic fire sprinklers are installed. The study also found that automatic sprinklers reduce fire damage up to 97 per cent, reduce water usage to fight a home fire by upwards of 90 per cent, and reduce the amount of water pollution released in the environment. The exhibition will be taking place at Walt Disney World® Resort. Over here the words of Professor Jose Torero still ring in this reporter’s ears from a conference a few years ago when he lamented fire engineers having missed the train when it came to influence at building design stage.

The National Fire Confederation or equivalent has the opportunity to make significant progress. My attention has already been drawn to the Business Sprinkler Alliance having pursued green issues with the UK Green Building Council, BRE and DCLG (see forthcoming issues of FIRE). We may not have Walt Disney but we do have the Ideal Home Show – would that not be a perfect occasion to pursue a similar venture?

The challenge now is, what can the Fire Sector do to progress this vital integration post haste? The only possible solution is uniting to campaign for inclusion and empowering the Confederation to ensure delivery. We will all then be willing to pay our subs and become involved, Local Government Association included, will we not? All we need is for another high-profile leader to lay down that gauntlet.

For more information on the US project visit: www.visionhousegreen.com

Posted May 8th, 2012 at 1520 by Andrew. Comment by emailing: andrew.lynch@pavpub.com 

 

Posted in David Milen, USA | Leave a comment

Anniversary terrorist attack warning

Security Correspondent Dr Dave Sloggett looks at the real possibility of terrorist attacks on a number of forthcoming dates.

This year marks the 60th year since Her Majesty the Queen ascended to the throne. The Jubilee celebrations provide an opportunity for the British public to show their feelings about her service and dedication to the country. Sadly in today’s uncertain world those celebrations will have to take place against a backdrop of increased security measures with which we have all had to become used to since the advent of trans-national terrorist groups like Al Qaeda and the resurgence of dissident Irish groups in Northern Ireland with their intent to re-commence a bombing campaign on the mainland.

For some involved in terrorism, anniversaries provide the ideal point at which to re-appear on the global stage. Mounting attacks on an anniversary adds weight to the significance of the event and will help ensure that the media give it additional coverage.

One example of this was the attack on 19th April 1995 on the FBI Hoover Building in Oklahoma. The perpetrator, Timothy McVeigh, deliberately targeted the FBI on the second anniversary of the end of the Waco siege in Texas. Despite Osama Bin Laden’s urgings the tenth anniversary of the attacks in New York and Washington on 11th September passed without major incident.

With hindsight this also showed the degree to which some of the disruptive measures being taken to neutralise the threat from Al Qaeda are working. The drone attacks in Pakistan and more recently in Yemen is one of a number of measures that have reduced their operational tempo on the world-stage. This had led Al Qaeda to change it tactics, calling now for potential recruits to act at home and avoid travelling to terrorist training camps. This tactical switch also widens the target list whilst their calls for Al Qaeda acolytes to ‘smash their fun loving society’ − targeting discothèques and public houses − brings back the images of the attacks in Bali on nightclubs and restaurants.

For the United Kingdom this all has a more immediate focus. With the start of the Olympic Games now less than 100 days away, several immediate anniversaries are of potential concern. The death of Bin Laden at the hands of Seal Team Six on the 1st of May occurs just two and a half weeks before the Olympic Torch starts its journey towards the opening ceremony. The arrival of the Torch could provide a cause celebre that could still be linked to the death of Bin Laden.

The anniversary of the attacks in London on 7th July 2005 could also provide a focal point for an act of terrorism. It happens to be the 50th day of the Torch’s journey and on that day it is visiting Cambridge. An attack on an iconic pillar of the establishment such as Cambridge on the day when seven years earlier 52 people died on the London Underground might prove tempting for a group of Al Qaeda followers or an individual acolyte. The 30th of June anniversary of the failed attack on Glasgow Airport is another potentially interesting date and is when the Torch passes through the middle of Birmingham.

The is no doubt other dates in the course of the journey of the Torch that might equally have some slightly more obscure connection into history. The date of the terrorist incident in Madrid was linked to an anniversary of a major battle many hundreds of years previously.

Clearly trying to anticipate that would be a futile exercise. But that does not reduce the need to be careful about the obvious dates. These are those which are closest to our collective memories often leaving a vivid imprint on the lives of those that remember the associated media coverage. To forget those and not be prepared would be hard to defend and be a form of collective dereliction of duty towards the public.

Anniversaries might well be the time for joyful celebration. They are also a time where a brief window of opportunity opens up for those whose celebrations would have a far more sinister objective.

 

Posted April 23rd, 2012 at 1130 by Andrew. Comment by emailing: andrew.lynch@pavpub.com 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in Dave Sloggett | Leave a comment

Sector rises to the sprinkler challenge

FIRE Editor Andrew Lynch reflects on a monumental boost for sprinkler installations in the UK

The biggest bug-bear for sprinkler campaigners the UK-over is not concerned with the mythical soap-opera-themed exploding sprinkler head, nor the fictitious fabric-tearing havoc wrought by installers. It is not even the unyielding obstinacy of the construction industry alongside seeming government insouciance. The biggest bug of all is cost.

I share their suffering.

One of my least favourite pastimes is having conversations with an accountant. Even worse is having conversations with an accountant about the cost-effectiveness of sprinkler installations. Worse still is having conversations with said accountant about the cost-effectiveness of sprinkler installations when he has already been won over on the moral side of the argument.

That said accountant is a friend and works for a housing association only exacerbates the torment. “Show me the money!” he shouts, or words to that effect.

Alas, the torment has ended. Angels of mercy from the British Automatic Sprinkler Association have published their report, Safer High-rise Living – The Callow Mount Sprinkler Retrofit Project, which tells a simple but compelling tale.

Firstly, it quashes those minor bug-bears. Installation is quick and easy amounting to minimal disruption, leaving no discernible trace. Just ask the residents – they’re delighted.

Now for the biggy. Estimated installation costs of £85,000 to £100,000 proved ridiculous. The whole project was brought in for £55,000: that’s for a 13 storey tower block with 47 flats. It works out at £1,148 for one flat. You’d struggle to buy a 3D TV for that.

In presenting their findings at yesterday’s launch in Westminster (http://www.fire-magazine.com/Content/Doc.aspx?id=3007) one of the speakers went some way to eradicating the myth of government insouciance (they do care really, they just don’t always know how to show it). Chief Fire and Rescue Advisor Sir Ken Knight welcomed the report’s findings on cost-effectiveness and appealed for housing owners to be made aware of its contents as part of their risk-profiling.

Given that this government is never going to introduce legislation, such support should be welcomed by the sprinkler lobby. The focus should now be placed upon changing guidance to ensure this report is included and target retrofitting sprinklers for those most at risk. This reporter agreed with both Sir Ken and London Fire Brigade Deputy Commissioner Rita Dexter when they made just such appeals.

Anyway, I digress. I was forgetting the figures. Check out the report: www.bafsa.org.uk

If it’s this cheap for retrofitting sprinklers in high-rise tower blocks, to such a high specification and standard, imagine how much cheaper for single-storey accommodation?

Take that to your councils and your residents and your accountants – it’s the most convincing evidence yet. It may even mean I stop getting shouted at.

 

Posted April 13th, 2012 at 1345 by Andrew. Comment by emailing: andrew.lynch@pavpub.com 

 

Posted in FIRE Editor | 1 Comment

Emerging need for a National Fire Congress

Following poor government advice during the fuel tanker dispute, FIRE Editor Andrew Lynch supports recent proposals for a high-level strategic body in the fire sector

There is a fine line between priming the public to be prepared and spreading blind panic. It was a line the government walked during the fuel tanker dispute with all the due care and attention of a staggering drunkard.

Whilst Prime Minister David Cameron defended the government’s approach to the fuel tanker dispute as somehow being “very calm, very sensible”, Cabinet Office Minister Francis Maude’s advice that “a bit of extra fuel in a jerry can is a sensible precaution to take”, was met with justifiable indignation by Fire Brigades Union General Secretary Matt Wrack.

He said that any stockpiling of fuel could have “disastrous” consequences. “This is not sensible advice − the general public does not properly understand the fire and explosion risk of storing fuel even if it was done sensibly.”

As he pointed out, it is against the law to store more than 10 litres of petrol in two proper five litre plastic containers in the home. It is very disturbing then that a government minister should be advocating what amounts to stockpiling highly flammable substances.

What also disturbs this reporter is the government’s complete failure to consult safety experts before going to press with ill thought-out recommendations. In this case it is obvious that fire sector experts should be the first port of call.

In the United States any member of Congress would know to consult or at the very least refer to guidance laid down by their own National Fire Protection Association. Here we do not, as yet, have the equivalent body. The Federation of British Fire Organisations and the Fire Sector Partnership have made significant strides forward, yet neither has managed to pull every stakeholder on board. The Fire Safety Advisory Board – one of the best things the last government did in the fire sector – was highly effective. However, the next government chose to disband it, possibly because it asserted too much influence.

Recent proposals to form an independent National Fire Congress – a strategic body constituted of all fire sector organisations – would fill this gap and would be the obvious consultation body for any fire-related issue. Come the next potential national emergency requiring a modicum of common sense, the minister in question could consult with those with superior knowledge, thereby avoid putting the public in peril again.

There has, however, been success in the past through informal liaisons which have forced through changes in legislation – look no further than the Foam Filled Furniture Regulations of the 1980s which have saved hundreds, possibly thousands of lives. CFO Brian Fuller, backbench MP Ian McCartney and the Fire Brigades Union came together to affect massive life-saving change. However, such initiatives are rare in the history of the Service, normally because they come up against powerful intransigence. I am reliably informed by some of those involved at the time that the Foam Filled Furniture Regulations had a particularly difficult opponent. Who? One Francis Maude no less.

There is a burgeoning desire to establish a high-level strategic body: a source for sound tactical advice is just one pressing need amongst many.

 

Posted April 3rd, 2012 at 1435 by Andrew. Comment by emailing: andrew.lynch@pavpub.com 

 

Posted in FIRE Editor | Leave a comment

A time for vigilance

FIRE’s Security Correspondent Dr Dave Sloggett warns against complacency in the lead up to the Olympics

As the terrorist threat in the United Kingdom appears to diminish as the time since the attempted attacks on the Haymarket and Glasgow Airport grows ever longer it is easy to understand why some people might become complacent. Sadly history shows that this is a dangerous attitude to take.

Today the United Kingdom literally faces a myriad of threats. Former members of the Irish Republican movement that remain outside the political process have embarked upon a course of development that can only lead to another act of terrorism on the mainland. Far right groups appear set on a confrontation with what they see as Liberal political leaders obsessed with a multi-cultural agenda.

Whilst their acts of terrorism to date remain uncoordinated and at a low scale the potential for that to change remains high as events in Norway last year highlighted. In Greece, Italy and Germany far-left groups have also been seen to be reacting to the increasingly strident activism being adopted by the Extreme Right Wing (XRW). Animal activists and other pressure groups also continue to conduct low level activities allowing them to avoid being labelled as terrorists.

To that complex picture we have to add the enduring threat from Muslim extremists. The lack of any recent attacks since the failed effort on Glasgow Airport highlight a number of problems facing trans-national groups such as Al Qaeda. Whilst the recruiting power of their famous narrative remains strong for many vulnerable people in society who question their social identity, the group itself is patently in a state of disarray.

Others might question the use of such language when it comes to describing a difficult and unpredictable phenomenon like trans-national terrorism. They might advocate using a slightly more modest description of the current situation suggesting their activities have been disrupted or that the organisation behind Al Qaeda is in transition. Without being drawn into semantic arguments it is clear that one of the reasons for the lack of recent terrorist attacks has been the degree to which the central Al Qaeda leadership, thought to be hiding in Pakistan, is being pressurised by drone attacks.  

One part of its response to the transition it is inevitably having to undergo in the wake of the death of Osama Bin Laden has been for Al Qaeda to instruct people not to travel overseas to train in terrorist training camps in places such as Pakistan but to conduct attacks as and when they can against any target they see fit. Evidence suggests that this instruction from Al Qaeda central is only partially being obeyed. The rumours of British citizens in Somalia have sufficient veracity about them to suggest that the much spoken off 50-100 Britons in Somalia at the moment is not the product of some wide guess.

The recent coverage of the movements of the former wife of one of the July 7 bombers in London, Jermaine Lindsay, in Kenya and across the border provide some additional verification of the problem. That British people continue to travel overseas to receive training in terrorism cannot be in doubt. Its just their numbers may well be down on those previously placed into the public domain.

Some acolytes of Al Qaeda have heeded the call to remain at home. In this case the lack of formal training that they would have received in terrorist training camps may well be leading to the individuals involved making a number of mistakes. This helps the security services. It is likely that on several occasions since Glasgow that people involved in nascent attempts to form groups have made mistakes that have seen them appear on the radar horizon of the security services.

The arrests mounted by the police and security services have had a material effect on the groups that are known to be active in the UK. They become more wary, taking time to establish the kind of trusted relationships needed to plan and execute an act of terrorism. That creates a sense of inertia in the terrorist planning cycle that those unfamiliar these effects could interpret as a broader indication of the imminent end of terrorist attacks in the UK.

Whilst the successes against home-grown terrorist groups is to be welcomed and certainly suggestive of a lack of complacency in the security services ahead of the Olympics and Diamond Jubilee celebrations this year it does not completely eradicate the potential for terrorism. Groups that are more sophisticated in their approach can remain off the radar horizon. The issue of how the security services manage limited resources came to the fore during Lady Justice Hallett’s Public Enquiry into the events of the 7 July 2005. The witness from the Security Service was clear in his evidence that on occasion’s confusion and uncertainty can exist in respect of the real identity of specific individuals whose activities for a short period of time come to their attention.

All this leads to an inevitable conclusion. Whilst the time since the last terrorist attack on the mainland grows the probability of another event does not diminish in some linear relationship. Far from it, almost the reverse is true. In mathematical terms the probability of another attack is related to the inverse of the measure of time that has passed. Whilst practically that is unlikely to be as simple an equation as suggested it does show that when the drivers for terrorism remain palpable that recruitment will continue to occur. Whilst that pipeline of recruits is present the potential for another attack remains high.

With recent events in Afghanistan providing yet another point of grievance to echo those used in the past such as the cartoons of the Prophet Muhammed that were published in Danish newspapers it is unlikely that the flow rate of recruits is about to diminish. In such circumstances and against the backdrop of the celebrations occurring this year it would be wise for everyone to remain vigilant not just the security services. Their resources are already busy. To catch those trying to operate off the radar horizon of the authorities requires the participation of society as a whole. A point illustrated so well by the actions of the Muslim community in Bristol when they showed their concern by reporting the activities of Andrew Ibrahim to the police.

It is to be hoped that the opportunity for a national celebration of the Queens Jubilee and the once in a lifetime chance to host the world’s greatest sporting event will not be lost in the aftermath and repercussions of a bloody repeat of the scenes of the 7 July 2005.

 

Posted March 22nd, 2012 at 1045 by Andrew. Comment by emailing: andrew.lynch@pavpub.com 

 

Posted in Dave Sloggett | Leave a comment

Reshaping Scotland’s fire and rescue services

Roseanna Cunningham, Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs, reports on the work underway to establish a new Scottish Fire and Rescue Service.

In September 2011, after sustained discussion, dialogue and debate over the past couple of years, the Scottish Government published proposals for a single Fire and Rescue Service in Scotland. This was a major milestone which marked the start of the biggest changes to the service in a generation.

Our legislation – which also proposes a single police service – is now being considered by the Scottish Parliament. Subject to Parliamentary approval, the Bill could be passed by the end of June.

A whole range of work is already underway to pave the way for the establishment of the new Scottish Fire and Rescue Service to replace the current eight services.

We’ve been working closely with the services, the trades unions and other key stakeholders towards a go live date of April 1, 2013. I realise that does not sound far away, but senior management in the services are confident the new single service will be ready for action by then. There will still, of course, be lots of work to do in the months and years afterwards to ensure it is a truly integrated single service with all the benefits that brings, but we can reassure the people of Scotland that they can continue to rely on the service in the future.

We have confirmed the interim headquarters for the new service will be in the beautiful and historic city of Perth. Although a longer-term decision on HQ location will be taken in due course, Perth will be an excellent first home for the new Scottish Fire and Rescue Service – it’s conveniently located in the heart of Scotland with excellent transport links.

And the recruitment process for the new Chief Officer will start in the Summer – even before the conclusion of the Parliamentary process – so we hope to be able to make an announcement on this in Autumn of this year.

It will undoubtedly be one of the most demanding and high-profile roles in civic Scotland and we expect a high level of interest. It is an exciting post which will be one of the top fire jobs in the UK and we are looking for the best candidate with the skills, expertise and knowledge to lead the new single service, regardless of where they currently work.

Heading up the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service, leading a workforce of more than 8,000 firefighters and support staff, with accountability for a multi-million pound budget and responsibility for ensuring the safety of more than five million people. That is a highly attractive proposition for anyone with ambitions and experience in the UK or even further afield.

And the new Chief Officer – whoever who he or she may be – will have the full backing of the Scottish Government as they focus on the job ahead of them. There are challenges, of course, but this a fantastic time to be living and working in Scotland. The new Scottish Fire and Rescue Service provides further evidence that we are looking to the future with confidence, delivering innovative solutions tailored to Scotland’s circumstances.

Against the backdrop of budget cuts by the Westminster government, reform of the fire and rescue services will help protect and improve local fire services – reducing duplication of support services eight times over and sustaining frontline services.

It will also give more equal access to specialist support and national capacity. So wherever and whenever services like urban search and rescue or line rescue are needed, the single service will be able to deploy them – regional boundaries and lines on maps will no longer be an issue.

And it will also strengthen the connection between services and communities, by creating a new formal relationship with each of the 32 local authorities, involving more local councillors and better integrating with community planning partnerships. A designated Local Senior Officer will work closely with the council, community and other partners to shape local fire priorities.

Who would not want to be a part of that?

Our services are strong and valued by communities across Scotland. Fire deaths are 50 per cent lower than they were a decade ago due to a concerted effort on improving community safety and we need to safeguard the hard-fought gains we have made and indeed continue to improve on them.

Working with the services, the unions, partners and communities, we have a once in a generation opportunity to reshape the Scotland’s fire and rescue services to ensure they are in the best possible shape, more efficient and effective and fit and ready for the challenges of the 21st Century. That is exactly what our proposals for new Scottish Fire and Rescue Service will do.

 

Posted March 22nd, 2012 at 1000 by Andrew. Comment by emailing: andrew.lynch@pavpub.com 

 

Posted in David Milen, USA | Leave a comment